This post may include affiliate links; see our disclosure policy.
This Everything Bagel pasta takes the magic of an everything bagel and makes it into a delicious vegetarian dinner. And it takes only 15 minutes to make!
A few weeks ago we went to New York City to cook on the TODAY Show from our new book, Pretty Simple Cooking. It was the first time Alex and I had been back to NYC since our teens! We’d been wanting to visit NYC for years, especially being so interested in food, but for whatever reason other trips got in the way. (Amalfi Coast, Rome, Greece, Santa Fe, Alaska…) So finally, we had an excuse to take a few days in the city and eat. Boy did we eat: and it inspired this Everything Bagel pasta recipe.
NYC restaurants, and an inspiration
New York City can be polarizing: you love it or your hate it. Well, Alex and I both absolutely love it. The architecture, the history, the melting pot of so many cultures, and the FOOD. It’s not even just the food itself: there’s an energy about just being around hundreds of years of food culture.
Living in Indianapolis, there’s not the rich history of food that you can immediately sense in NYC. (We hope NYC is a peek into what Indianapolis restaurants could be someday.) We’ve had some incredible meals in new York. Notably: Dirt Candy, a truly inventive vegetarian restaurant run by a woman chef, and my favorite Via Carrota, the best Italian I’ve had outside of Italy.
But the recipe today was inspired by a low brow New York City culinary experience: the bagel.
Everything Bagel seasoning…on pasta
Yes, the bagel. While we were in NYC, Alex was determined to find a good bagel joint. I was very into bagels in college, but later in life found out that they weren’t quite the model of a health food. Since then, I’ve largely avoided bagels so as not to engage my previous obsession.
But in this case, I figured: when in Rome, right? When in NYC, eat a bagel. I had forgotten about my obsession with Everything Bagel flavor until I stepped into that bagel shop. The aroma of fresh bagels and the light oniony garlicy Everything Bagel seasoning smell brought back all sorts of memories. My Everything Bagel was slathered with an extreme amount of garden herb cream cheese, and it was everything a bagel experience should be: gooey, savory, creamy, salty, and in seedy goodness.
Since bagels aren’t part of our every day life, I thought: what if we could bottle up the Everything Bagel and put it into a meal? Like, Everything Bagel pasta?
How to make Everything Bagel pasta
Everything Bagel pasta? Yes. One thousand times, yes. This Everything Bagel pasta is everything you love about the Everything Bagel, reconstructed into pasta. And it’s so, so simple: it takes just 3 ingredients and 15 minutes to make! It’s actually surprising how well it turned out.
When I told Alex I was going to test run this Everything Bagel pasta, he wasn’t sure if my idea of combining cream cheese with pasta water and Everything Bagel seasoning was too simple. But when he took the first bite, he was sold. It tastes just like an Everything Bagel! And the Everything Bagel pasta was born. A few notes about this Everything Bagel pasta:
- Our Everything Bagel pasta features our Homemade Everything Bagel seasoning. Of course, you could certainly use purchased Everything Bagel seasoning to make it even simpler.
- For a healthy dinner, we suggest pairing the Everything Bagel pasta with some green for a healthy dinner: here we used sauteed broccoli. Or, make a fresh green salad.
- For the sauce, cream cheese is combined with some of the pasta water to make a creamy sauce. The amount of water will vary, so add just enough until your pasta becomes very creamy.
- The pasta is best served immediately. It becomes a bit sticky as it sits; if desired, you can reheat it in the serving pot and add a bit more pasta water and salt. Next day leftovers will have a stickier consistency.
- We’ve added a few ideas for optional garnishes: sliced green onion tops for a “scallion cream cheese” option, or a bit of grated Parmesan for a sophisticated flair. But we love it as is: pure and simple!
Related: Easy Dinner Recipes for Busy Lives
This recipe is…
Vegetarian, gluten-free with gluten-free pasta.
A few more fast & easy dinner recipes
In addition to this Everything Bagel pasta, here a few more of our favorite fast and easy dinner recipes:
- Easy Dal Makhani
- Pasta Puttanesca Recipe
- Stir Fry Vegetables with Teriyaki
- Tex Mex Migas
- Avocado Black Bean Quesadilla
- Thai Curry Pizza with Naan Bread
- All Easy Dinner Ideas!
Everything Bagel Pasta
This Everything Bagel Pasta takes the magic of an Everything Bagel and puts it into delicious dinner form. It takes only 15 minutes to make this simple vegetarian dinner recipe!
- Prep Time: 5 minutes
- Cook Time: 10 minutes
- Total Time: 15 minutes
- Yield: 3 to 4 1x
- Category: Main Dish
- Method: Stovetop
- Cuisine: American
Ingredients
- 8 ounces pasta
- ½ cup full-fat cream cheese (1/2 block)
- 1 ½ tablespoons Everything Bagel Seasoning
- Kosher salt, to taste
Instructions
- Bring a large pot of well-salted water to a boil. Cook the pasta until it is al dente (refer to the package instructions). Using a glass liquid measuring cup, reserve ¾ cup of the hot pasta water, then drain the pasta.
- Return the pasta to the pot. Add the cream cheese, broken into dollops, and Everything Bagel Seasoning. Pour in about ⅓ cup of the pasta water and toss until a creamy sauce forms; add a bit of additional water as necessary to come to a creamy consistency. Taste and add additional salt, if desired (depending on how much pasta water is added).
- The pasta is best served immediately. Leftovers last refrigerated for up to 3 days.
Notes
Optional garnishes: for a “scallion cream cheese” variation, add thinly sliced green onion tops; for a sophisticated variation, add a sprinkle of grated Parmesan cheese.
I have to make this! I was thinking about topping it with smoked salmon and adding some leafy greens to the sauce. Do you think baby kale and arugula would work for this?
Yes, I think that’d be great!
I actually did try this. It tasted like an everything bagel, and it really was 15 minutes from start to finish. Served to dinner guests with a salad (bagged) and garlic bread (premade) for a quick prep meatless monday.
I would add tomatoes and cracked pepper next time, because thats my favorite way to eat an everything bagel.
This is good to have on pasta rotation.
Oh fantastic — we love to hear that this made for a super simple Meatless Monday dinner party — yay! I love the idea of adding tomatoes — is that sundried tomatoes or fresh? Either way: yum!
Hi,
Made this tonight! Let me tell you it was a hit. Everyone loved it! I used Trader Joe’s Everthing Bagel mix. Will definitely be going on my rotation! Thank you!
We are so so glad to hear it was a hit! Thank you so much for making it!
Hi Lovely Folks,
I would love to try this but I have a very heavy conscience about the cream cheese. Too much holiday eating! ;-) I’m wondering if plain (or scallion tofu cream cheese would work. Thoughts?
Nice to hear from you! I haven’t tried tofu cream cheese, but I’m assuming it would work? You could also try cashew cream like the one in our creamy vegan pasta marinara for a vegan option — it’s not the same but would still have a salty, savory note. I would just eyeball the quantities — you probably wouldn’t need as much kosher salt since the cashew cream is saltier than cream cheese. Good luck!
Love this idea! I’d eat that seasoning on anything!
Everything Bagel Pasta. What? I am dead. You guys are genius, xo.
Of course I love NYC since our daughter lives there. You are so right about the food!
This looks yummy and quick.
GET OUT OF TOWN WITH THIS! Such a fabulous idea. I mean, who can resist everything bagel flavored, well, everything! Love love love! So glad you guys enjoyed NYC!
Will do! :)
Made it last week, and loved it! I used 3 TB & 1 tsp of Trader Joe’s Everything Bagel seasoning & it was perfect!
I have the jar of Everything Bagel seasoning from Trader Joe’s-how much do you think I’d use?
Thanks!
Great question! Adding up the volume of our homemade seasoning, we’d say about 3 to 4 tablespoons to taste. Would you be able to try it and let us know how much of the seasoning you added? We could update the recipe accordingly!
OMG! My two favorite things! This may be on our menu this week!
Ooo we’d love that! Let us know if you try it!